Sciweavers

Share
SYNTHESE
2008

The inclosure scheme and the solution to the paradoxes of self-reference

9 years 5 months ago
The inclosure scheme and the solution to the paradoxes of self-reference
All paradoxes of self-reference seem to share some structural features. Russell in 1908 and especially Priest nowadays have advanced structural descriptions that successfully identify necessary conditions for having a paradox of this kind. I examine in this paper Priest's description of these paradoxes, the Inclosure Scheme (IS), and consider in what sense it may help us understand and solve the problems they pose. However, I also consider the limitations of this kind of structural descriptions and give arguments against Priest's use of IS in favour of dialetheism. IS fails to identify sufficient conditions for having a paradox of self-reference. That means that, even if we identified a problem common to any reasoning satisfying IS, that problem would not explain why some of those reasonings are paradoxical and some others are not. Therefore IS cannot justify by itself the claim that some particular theory offers the best solution to the paradoxes of self-reference. We still ...
Jordi Valor Abad
Added 28 Dec 2010
Updated 28 Dec 2010
Type Journal
Year 2008
Where SYNTHESE
Authors Jordi Valor Abad
Comments (0)
books